Sunday, June 27, 2010

Editoral-Long trials and escapes

UNDERTRIAL prisoners handcuffed or in fetters and further hooked to the belt of escorting policemen have been escaping from the Karachi City Courts’ compound for as long as one can remember. Such escapes are much more frequent and daring now than previously.

The June 19 escape won’t be the last but it is unlikely that the escapes yet to happen will cast the law and order administration in a worse light or cause greater panic.

Just imagine, four deadly sectarian suspects guarded by only two constables loitering around the court compound hours after the hearing was over and remaining in touch with their rescuers on cellphones. The casualness of it all has justifiably given rise to suspicions of collusion between the police (at whatever level) and the rescuers belonging to a banned militant organisation.

The jail and police superintendents would surely tell us that they could spare no more than two men to guard the four terrorists and that they did not have the means to arrange for a separate vehicle to carry them to court. But they would never tell us the number of armed men and vehicles that guard and escort their commanders and political bosses. The brunt of the escape inquiry, quite obviously, shall have to be borne by the surviving policemen.

Such is the history of official enquiries instituted to determine culpability. This one will drag on as did the inquires in the previous escapes. Never mind that. Millions have been spent, the UN has been involved and two years have gone by. But Benazir Bhutto’s murder inquiry is hanging fire.

Criminal trials last for years but the rate of conviction is less than 10 per cent. Before a trial proceeds the complainant, his witnesses and counsel, the state prosecutor, the accused and their counsel all have to be there in court together.

Trials are routinely put off if the summons are not served, the counsels are busy in higher courts, the presiding officer falls ill or, more commonly, if the undertrial prisoners are not brought from jail because either the escort force has another security/protocol assignment or the aging vehicle bringing the prisoners has stalled.

It is a rare occasion when all these elements fall in line and a witness or two are examined before the court time runs out and then one has to wait for another fortuitous day when everybody is able to assemble.

Longwinded trials, usually ending in acquittal, are the chief cause of discontent in the Frontier regions where the jirgas would decide even murder cases in a session or two before Pakistan’s penal laws applied there.

Of all the factors delaying trials, the most common is the inability, or unwillingness, of the jail or police authorities (it is their joint responsibility) to bring prisoners to court.

If the transportation of prisoners were to be eliminated from the process not only would trials proceed expeditiously, the hazard of prisoners escaping would also lessen. It would also put an end to the abuse of official authority in a variety of ways. For instance, it is not uncommon for a resourceful prisoner to make a diversion on the return journey to spend time with his friends or family.

It was primarily with this consideration in view that this writer had proposed to the Asian Development Bank (ADB) in 2002, when it launched its $350m Access-to-Justice programme for Pakistan, that criminal courts and jails, wherever possible, should be located contiguous to each other inside a single walled compound.

As an example, it appears eminently feasible to build all the needed courtrooms next to Karachi’s centrally situated Central Jail. The vast jail area can be curtailed to accommodate only undertrial prisoners and the jail at Landhi can be expanded to accommodate all the convicts and other detainees who are not required to be produced before the court at short intervals.

Under the ADB programme a large building for courts was constructed in Malir which has indeed reduced congestion in the courts but the requirement of police personnel and vans to transport the prisoners, if at all, has increased. Trials through video link between the jail and court which were envisaged in the programme and attempted in Lahore, it is believed, also ran into legal difficulties and had to be abandoned.Mention must be made of the ADB’s contribution to the streamlining of training of civil judges and judicial magistrates and in improving their service conditions. Now they are believed to be paid twice as much as their counterparts in the executive or developmental cadres. Chief Justice Iftikhar Chaudhry has been indulgent enough to provide cars to them. Society must not forgive them if they still shirk their work or indulge in corruption — which some indeed do.

Though the Access-to-Justice programme has since been wound up, the feasibility of bringing jails and criminal courts together still deserves to be examined. Karachi’s City Courts then should be able to house all the civil, special and appellate courts that lie scattered all over the city in improvised buildings. Besides solving the escort and conveyance problem it would be of great convenience to litigants and lawyers.If this kind of arrangement makes criminal trials expeditious and, at the same time, reduces the chances of dangerous criminals running away or being rescued, investment and disruption in implementing it would have been amply rewarded.

In the long run it would also save money and time and, hopefully, reduce bribery. All said, a mystery remains. Why did the escapees of June 19 have to be tried in the City Courts when even robbers and kidnappers are often tried in a makeshift courtroom inside the Central Jail?

kunwaridris@hotmail.com

Editoral-No movement

Pakistan rolled out the red carpet for Indian Home Minister P. Chidambaram on Saturday, the grand welcome an attempt to establish the government’s bona fides as a genuine partner in peace.

The ongoing thaw in relations will continue with the July 15 meeting between the foreign ministers of India and Pakistan, but the same unanswered questions continue to linger in the air ever since Prime Minister Singh and Prime Minister Gilani made their ‘breakthrough’ in March. What is apparent by now is that the Indian tone when it comes to Pakistan has changed. But there seems to have been little to no movement in terms of substance so far. Even if it has stopped saying so quite as insistently as previously, India continues to put the terrorism issue first. At the very least, India wants the trial of the men held here in connection with the Mumbai attacks to be completed speedily. Beyond that it wants some firm kind of response against, specifically, the Laskhar-i-Taiba, the group that India believes was behind the Mumbai attacks, and, more generally, other ‘India-centric’ militant groups here.

The problem on this side in regard to those core Indian demands is twofold. One, the army’s ‘prioritisation approach’ in the fight against militancy means that the India-centric groups are much lower down the ladder in terms of priority. Two, with the army wary of Indian activities in Afghanistan, the growing military threat India represents on Pakistan’s eastern border and the long-standing Kashmir and water issues, there is a sense that there is virtually no possibility that Pakistan will do something simply because India demands it, even if circuitously through the international community.

Therein lies the problem. If change in tone does not lead to a change in substantive positions, at least on the issue of talking — and talking about the issues, not talks about talks — then Pakistan and India look set to continue this delicate diplomatic dance that convinces no one. Of course, just as Prime Minister Singh surprised the world in March by seemingly breaking from India’s post-Mumbai stance towards Pakistan, there is a possibility of another surprise being pulled from the diplomatic hat. So on the caravan of hope must move, to July 15. Privately, Indian officials are not very upbeat about the possibility of any major breakthrough then, which means that the caravan of hope risks becoming a diplomatic circus. The governments of India and Pakistan owe it to their people to do all that can be done to move their nations closer towards the path of peace. Anything less, and the perpetrators of Mumbai would have won.

Editoral-Terror suspects

There is no doubt that the criminal justice system in Pakistan needs to undergo a major overhaul. In this respect Sindh Home Minister Zulfiqar Mirza’s recent remarks in the provincial assembly criticising the judiciary have raised some pertinent questions that need to be addressed by all stakeholders.

The minister claimed that the judiciary was actually letting suspected terrorists caught “red-handed” off the hook. He added that hundreds of people — including terrorists arrested for “heinous crimes” — had been released by the courts since 2002. The minister’s comments are not unfounded. Notorious individuals with evidently strong links to banned outfits have been known to walk free in this country because of ‘lack of evidence’. Dr Mirza wants the courts to give the benefit of the doubt to the prosecution in cases of terrorism.

Observers have also pointed out that a defective investigation process is the main reason why suspects are allowed to walk free. Also, eyewitnesses and victims often refuse to testify in court or identify the suspects for fear of their lives. Trials in this country can drag on for years and the low conviction rate is no secret. When the legal system fails, extra-legal means are employed to deal with suspects. This, coupled with the fact that suspected terrorists are freed due to shoddy investigations, is a recipe for disaster. Clearly the solution to bringing terrorists and other hardened criminals to justice is an empowered, effective legal system complemented by modern methods of investigation. The legal lacunae which allow suspects to walk free must be plugged while law-enforcement agencies need to vastly improve the way in which they probe cases. All organs of the state must play their part in overhauling the criminal justice system. The executive cannot afford to be complacent and allow anti-terrorism laws to lapse, as in the case of the Anti-Terrorism (Amendment) Ordinance 2010. On the other hand, the courts must convict and sentence terror suspects if credible evidence is produced. It has also been pointed out that comprehensive anti-terror legislation — which is currently lacking — would at least provide a base for legal action against those who practise violence.

Editoral-Militant education

A report by the Brookings Institution has belatedly discovered what academics in Pakistan have been saying for over a decade. It is now being pointed out that the public school system in the country stokes militancy in Pakistan more than anything else.

The inadequacies of the education system are usually cited as risk factors and the report endorses this view. The fact is that the curricula and textbooks, said to have been under revision since 9/11, are responsible for promoting a narrow worldview and a culture of bigotry. Young minds have been exposed to literature that celebrates jihad and glorifies religion by stirring hatred against non-Muslims. Along with the religiosity spewed by many television channels, school books have helped create regressive mindsets that the madressahs approve of. If the religious schools have had a smaller impact it is not because they are more tolerant but because their relatively low enrolment rate limits their reach.

The failure of the public-sector school system — it hardly functions and has not expanded sufficiently — has left many children out in the cold. The private sector that is being encouraged very often cannot provide affordable education to the poor. Even though enrolment is shown as having grown, most children in government schools cannot claim to be benefiting from education of a kind that trains them to become productive and enlightened adults. If anything, rising expectations and the failure to provide the youth opportunities for education and jobs have led to frustration, creating a fertile breeding ground for militancy. The only solution lies in addressing the education sector holistically. The immediate need is to expedite the curricula and textbook reform process, launch a massive teachers’ training programme to raise the standard of pedagogy and install a monitoring mechanism to ensure that schools actually function.

Rehman, Chidambaram vow to fight terror together

ISLAMABAD, June 26: Pakistan and India left little doubt on Saturday that the distrust nagging them since the Nov 2008 attacks in Mumbai would not go away soon as Interior Minister P. Chidambaram urged Islamabad to try more suspects for the strikes.

His counterpart promptly countered the demand, saying “we should respect verdicts by our courts”.

The two ministers made the remarks at a joint press conference after the conclusion of Mr Chidambaram’s two-day visit, during which he also attended the Saarc interior ministers’ meeting.

In an upbeat note, however, they said the two governments had agreed to fight terrorism jointly.

Mr Chidambaram’s remarks about the trials came in reply to a journalist’s question. He said: “Nobody is questioning anyone’s intentions. It is the outcome that will decide whether we are on the right track or not.

“We should allow the outcome to become visible. We have agreed that there are certain outcomes that we are looking forward to.”

Rehman Malik was asked whether a new case would be filed against Hafiz Saeed, the leader of Jamaatud Dawa. The minister replied: “We respect our courts. If our Supreme Court has given judgment, we ought to respect it. The new evidence and the new dossier that has come to us are being looked into. We are looking into dossier and information and we will move accordingly.”

Mr Chidambaram countered the assertion: “The outcome that we are expecting that rigorous investigation will follow up the leads that are available, all the masterminds and handlers behind the 26/11 attacks must be brought to justice, and at the same time we must ensure that terrorists have no free run either in Pakistan or India.

“Both countries must work together as well as with other counties of South Asia to wipe out terrorism.”

JOINT FIGHT: The two ministers said they had agreed to enhance intelligence sharing between the Federal Investigation Agency and India’s Central Bureau of Intelligence. The agencies would jointly look into acts of terrorism, including the Mumbai attacks.

“We will work together to clear this menace (terrorism) and I am grateful for the wisdom and leadership he (Mr Chidambaram) has shown during the Saarc conference and suggestion he made have been widely respected and included in the draft report,” Mr Malik said.

“Our FIA and Indian CBI will interact with each other on the matter of terrorism, including Mumbai blasts. I think both nations want good relations and friendship between us. It is very good beginning and we will take it to the positive end.”

Mr Malik said the two sides had decided to work together and give a very clear massage to terrorists that “we are united and stand together”.

Mr Chidambaram said: “We come to end of the Saarc ministerial meeting. We have had a productive meeting today.”

The Indian home minister also met President Asif Ali Zardari and Prime Minister Yousuf Raza Gilani.

“I will leave with the conviction that we both have exchanged views and understood requirement of the situation. We have agreed that we should address this situation with seriousness that it deserves.

“I will go back with confidence that outcome of our mutual interaction will be very good for both countries.”

Mr Malik described his one-on-one meeting with Mr Chidambaram as one of his best so far. “We have had the best meeting. Let us be positive and promote harmony.”

Endorsing the resolve of his Indian counterpart against terrorism, Mr Malik said that the fight against terrorism and extremism would be taken to a “logical conclusion”.

Three F-16 aircraft arrive

ISLAMABAD, June 26: The first batch of the latest version of F-16 fighters arrived at PAF’s Shahbaz air base in Jacobabad on Saturday as part of the delivery of 18 high-tech aircraft from the United States.

Pakistani pilots, who received training on the fighters in the US, flew the three aircraft to the base, a PAF spokesman said.

Pakistan attaches great significance to its air defence needs, the spokesman said, adding that a contract was signed with the US in 2005-06 for the acquisition of 18 F-16 C/D Block-52 aircraft. PAF would receive these aircraft in batches and the delivery of all 18 aircraft would complete by the end of this year.

Air Marshal Mohammad Hassan, Deputy Chief of the Air Staff (Operations), and Air Marshal Waseemuddin, Deputy Chief of the Air Staff (Administration), received the aircraft.

The new version of F-16s is equipped with advanced avionics suite and latest weapons with night precision attack capability.

These are much superior to the F-16 A/Bs already in the inventory of the Pakistan Air Force, the spokesman said.

General Norton A. Schwartz, Chief of the Staff of US Air Force, has arrived to attend the formal handing over of F-16 planes to Pakistan.

The three aircraft would be inducted into the PAF at the newly upgraded base in Jacobabad under the Southern Air Command of the country on Sunday.

The Shahbaz base was earlier used as a ‘forward operating base’ of the PAF, but recently it was upgraded to handle the new F-16 fighter jets.

Terror declared biggest challenge facing region

ISLAMABAD: The four-day Saarc interior ministers’ conference concluded here on Saturday with pledges for effective multilateral cooperation to tackle terrorism. It declared terrorism as the “biggest challenge facing the region”.

The meeting discussed ways to strengthen police cooperation and step up real-time intelligence sharing and other means to combat terrorism that has afflicted the region.

Member countries agreed to consider a proposal forwarded by Pakistan to create an institution similar to Interpol.

The participants of the conference agreed that a centre would be set up at the Saarc headquarters to check financiers of terrorism and banned outfits. They resolved that they would ensure that their soil was not used for terrorist activities.

Some analysts believed that the meeting could not take any concrete step and that member countries did not step forward from where they stood in Colombo over two years ago. They were of the view that taking a decision regarding formation of Saarc police was a good step towards curbing crimes and terrorism, but no step was suggested in the conference to implement the decision.

Saarc Secretary-General Sheel Kant Sharma said at a press conference that the meeting expressed concern over the continuing scourge of terrorism afflicting the region which had caused extensive loss of human life, destruction and damage to property.

It was agreed in the ministerial level meeting that the member countries would extend cooperation to each other against terrorism while remaining within the purview of national laws and procedures and international commitments and following the principle of non-interference and non-intervention in each others’ affairs.

The conference declared that terrorism posed a serious threat to peace and security, expressed deep concern over continuing scourge of terrorism afflicting the region which has caused extensive loss of human life, destruction and damage to property, took a note of the fact that peace and harmony, friendly and good neighbourly relations and cooperation and prosperity of the region are being threatened by terrorism.

Interior Minister Rehman Malik highlighted the objectives of the conference and spelt out Pakistan’s policy, the central point of which was to seek regional cooperation to address the challenges at hand.

Islamabad talks in ‘our interest’, says US

WASHINGTON: The United States has said that increasing contacts between India and Pakistan not only served their own interests but also suited the larger US interests in the region.

At a briefing in Washington, State Department spokesman Phillip J. Crowley noted that the latest round of India-Pakistan talks in Islamabad represented a step in the right direction.

“Just as we’ve said many, many times, we appreciate and certainly endorse increasing dialogue between Pakistan and India,” Mr Crowley said.

“It is in their self-interest and our larger interest to see dialogue that can help to resolve tensions that exist between the two countries.”

The US comments followed a meeting between the interior and foreign secretaries of the two countries in Islamabad this week.

Indian Home Minister P. Chidambaram, the first member of the Indian cabinet to visit Pakistan since the 26/11 terror attack, is also the first Indian home minister to visit Islamabad in three decades. He went to Islamabad to participate in the Saarc home ministers’ conference.

On Thursday, Indian Foreign Secretary Nirupama Rao held talks with Foreign Secretary Salman Bashir, which focussed on trust-building measures between the two countries.—Correspondent

Mistrust marks ISI-CIA ties: US

ISLAMABAD: American officials have told Pakistan that there is mistrust between the Central Intelligence Agency (CIA) and the Inter Services Intelligence (ISI).

“John Tierney (the chairman of the House Armed Services Committee of the US Congress) told a Pakistani delegation that there is mistrust between the CIA and ISI,” according to a report of the Senate’s standing committee on defence about a visit by its members to the US last month.

The 17-page official report, which has been drafted by Iftikharullah Babar, secretary of the Senate committee under the supervision of Senator Javed Ashraf Qazi and a copy of which is also available to Dawn seems to be a revealing document regarding the thinking of the US establishment towards Pakistan.

This is for the first time that the US administration has expressed their views in front of any parliamentarian delegation which was visiting US on the official invitation of David Price, Chairman of House Democracy Partnership.

Qazi who originally hails from PML-Q but PPP led group of present coalition partners also supported him for this slot as he had worked with late Benazir Bhutto as DG ISI in her last tenure in the government 1993 to 1996. He also enjoys the confidence of President Zardari since late 90’s.

Qazi has been described as “man of many secrets” by one of the best seller books on Pakistan Army, “Cross Swords” has a wide experience of intelligence as he has headed ISI between 1993 to 1995 and Military Intelligence from 1990 to 1991.

Qazi who had headed both ISI (1993-95) and Military Intelligence (1990-1991) , while leading the committee delegation in US held extensive meetings with the some key members of the US establishment including one CIA official whose name has intentionally not been mentioned in the report and Richard Holbrooke the US Special Envoy for Pakistan and Afghanistan.

Under the title of “Meeting with Senior Official of CIA” report mentions that the delegation had a meeting with the official (whose name has not been mentioned) on May 19th. The CIA official informed the delegation that 40 personnel of the Agency are dedicated to liaise with the Congress. He asked as to how the Defense Committee conducts oversight of the Intelligence Agencies in Pakistan. Senator Lt.Gen. (R) Javed Ashraf responded that the Defense Committee has not performed that role so far.

The committee can do it but it cannot stop their funding since the Senate has no power to appropriate funds.

In a luncheon meeting with Representative John Tierney, the Senator told the delegation that there is mistrust between the CIA and ISI. To this Qazi said this perception was baffling because ISI and CIA are working closely together in this war and there is no such feeling on the ISI side. Qazi warned, “If the mistrust message is conveyed back home it would be taken seriously. CIA should clarify to the Congress if their relationship with ISI is good.

On the contrary the unnamed CIA official who met with the committee members responded that it seems CIA has not done a good job explaining things to Representatives Tierney but the CIA Director and all of us at CIA are appreciative of the cooperation by ISI. He stated that CIA has a history of sixty years and the Congress has gradually strengthened its oversight role. CIA deals with congress as a customer and provides it information.

CIA shares sensitive information with a small select group in the Intelligence Committee and very sensitive information with two senators and two Congressmen only. Director CIA reports to the Director of National Intelligence.

He can also go to the US President directly. Director CIA is appointed by the President and confirmed by Congress. Director, National Intelligence basically coordinates between different intelligence agencies, CIA sends brief to the President, which has in put from other agencies as well.

Oversight: Senator Lt-General (retired) Javed Ashraf who has been described as “man of many secrets” in a best seller book “Cross Swords” on Pakistan Army , stated that oversight role of the US congress on defense matters is not impartial as individual Senators and Congressmen influence the setting up of large manufacturing units in their constituencies and oppose their should down to please their constituents. He said that the next step for the Senate Defense Committee may also include an oversight of the intelligence agencies. At times things done by IB are blamed on ISI and vice versa due to lack of any coordinating setup.

In reply to a question the CIA operative said that sharing the level of information on covert/overt operations with Congress is determined by the President. In the past some opportunities were lost due to seeking approval from the Congress. However, the hands of CIA are not completely tried and it does enjoy some flexibility in its working.

Richard Holbrooke accuses ISI: The US special representative Richard Holbrooke in his meeting with a parliamentary delegation visiting US last month indirectly accused Pakistan and premier Pakistani intelligence agency Inter Services Intelligence (ISI) for knowing the whereabouts of Mullah Omar the at large Amir of Afghan Taliban.

“People in the US think that Pakistan authorities know where Mullah Omar is. If nobody in the ISI can do anything without the knowledge of DG ISI , he is not telling,” said Richard Holbrooke in a meeting with the members of the Senate Standing Committee on Defense headed by Senator Lt.General (retired) Javed Ashraf Qazi a report of the committee members US visit also available to Dawn revealed this here on Saturday. The report has at length mentioned the details of discussions of the committee members with the US State Department, Senate, Congress and CIA.

While discussing about the meeting with Richard Holbrooke the report says that Holbrooke told that members of the committee that India is angry about the release of Hafiz Saeed the chief of a militant charity organization Jammat Jammat ud Dawa about which Javed Ashraf Qazi rebutted the Indian claim by saying that he was released by the courts due to the lack of evidence.

Sacrifices of ISI:

Sixty nine years old Qazi who also had served as Communication and Education Minister in different times argued in favor of his former department ISI number of times during his official visit to the US. At one point during a meeting with Senator Robert Casey , Chairman Sub Committee of Foreign Relations on Near Eastern and South and Central Asian Affairs, while defending the blames against ISI regarding its secret ties with Taliban he mentioned the sacrifices rendered by the ISI during the on going war on terror. He said that three ISI headquarters have been destroyed and almost 300 causalities have been inflicted on ISI in this war. How can ISI have sympathy with Taliban?

Saturday, June 26, 2010

Editoral-OTHER VOICES - Sri Lankan Press Food choices

CHOICE … is a hallmark [of] a healthy democracy. One may therefore say in a … democracy people are expected to have a fairly varied choice of food. However it is not always [as] simple as that. Take Sri Lanka for instance. When J.R. Jayewardene opened the floodgates of the open economy to give relief to people who were under the extreme protectionist measures adopted by the Sirimavo Bandaranaike government, rice-eating Sri Lankans were given an array of choices. The move went on to make bread one of the three main [staples] of many Sri Lankans. Wheat flour poured into [the] country. So [did] rice from India, Pakistan and many other countries for much cheaper prices. The local farmers obviously saw no point in cultivating rice and just gave it up.

Over the next three decades some 80 per cent of paddy land in Sri Lanka was abandoned. Almost every government that came to power during this period promised to look into farmer grievances. Ad hoc measures like import taxes were introduced … to curb the tide of imports. However … they lost interest and let market forces have their way. [Recently] the government went on to re-impose the … duty on wheat imports…. The imposition … saw Prima jacking up its flour prices … and the All Ceylon Bakery Owners Association increasing the price of bread…. A few years ago a similar move … yielded results triggering a drastic drop in bread consumption. Even otherwise the consumption of bread is on the decline here. With the price of most consumed varieties of rice starting from Rs60 and bread prices now standing at Rs45 and above, once again a significant drop in bread consumption is expected. Similar measures have been adopted by countries like China and many in the socialist bloc [which] triggered lifestyle changes in the best interest of the farmer and the health of the consumer. However all those countries had consistency in policy…. Sri Lanka unfortunately is yet to come up with a set of proposals like those. — (June 24)

Editoral-Civilian control of military

By Shada Islam
Saturday, 26 Jun, 2010
US PRESIDENT Barack Obama’s decision to fire Gen Stanley McChrystal for engaging in conduct which “undermines the civilian control of the military” has strong lessons for Pakistan, Turkey and Thailand, three modern-day democracies that I know well and where tensions between the civilian government and a restless military continue to darken the landscape.

Real democracy demands an end to army domination, the elimination of all military control over the national agenda and, as President Obama pointed out, it puts civilians in control of the military, not the other way around. But try telling that to the impatient men in uniform in Islamabad, Istanbul and Bangkok. Not to mention Bangladesh and Myanmar.

These and other countries where armies strain at the leash share several unfortunate similarities: weak civilian institutions, often accused of corruption and nepotism, contrasted with a strong, modern and efficient army which is called on to ‘save the nation when times get bad.

The end result of such coups or military interventions, however, is almost always the reverse of what is expected. As in the case of Pakistan, the generals operate no differently from the civilians (why should they, since they come from similar backgrounds?), corruption abounds and when push comes to shove, often from the frustrated public, the army retreats out of the public eye but endeavours to keep the reins of power firmly in its hands.

The overarching argument is security: in Pakistan’s case the ‘threat’ posed by India, in Turkey, it’s the Kurdish minority in Thailand, the so-called red-shirts who back former Thai Prime Minister Thaksin Shinawatra. If only life were that simple.

The Burmese case is particularly poignant. The generals in the country appear too firmly entrenched to allow any dreams of democracy to flourish. Democracy icon and opposition leader Aung San Suu Kyi has just marked her 65th birthday, under house arrest. The Nobel laureate has been in detention for almost 15 years and has been barred from running in upcoming elections that critics have denounced as a sham aimed at entrenching the generals’ power. Suu Kyi’s party won the last polls in 1990 but was never allowed to take office.

The Burmese generals could, if they wanted to, learn a lesson or two about democratisation from neighbouring Indonesia where the transition to democracy from army-backed authoritarian rule has been one of the most dramatic — and heartening — political events of the late 20th century. Although sometimes painful, the transition has brought back freedoms to Indonesia that have not been seen since the country’s first, short-lived experiment with democracy in the 1950s.

Interestingly, Indonesian President Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono, who was sworn in for a second five-year term last year, is a dictator’s loyal soldier who is now transformed into the leader of a thriving but messy democracy. A former senior general during the Suharto dictatorship, the taciturn 60-year-old, with a penchant for singing romantic songs, has become a standard-bearer for Indonesia’s reform. Rising to power in the country’s first direct presidential election in 2004, Yudhoyono is credited with years of relative stability and prosperity which won him a decisive election victory last July.

Although the country has yet to tackle all its problems, including corruption, the Indonesian army is firmly in the barracks, leaving the civilian government in charge. And SBY as he is called affectionately will be strutting his stuff at the G20 meeting on June 26, confirming Indonesia’s status as an internationally respected, thriving democracy.Not too far away to the north, the military domination of South Korea ended firmly with the 1997 presidential election and peaceful transition of power to Kim Dae-jung, a lifelong democracy and human rights activist. And in Latin America, dictatorships have given way to elected leaders in many nations.

Readers of this paper hardly need further depressing confirmation of the pervasive presence of the army in Pakistan. The European Union is careful to maintain contacts only with Pakistani civilian leaders — while Gen Kayani keeps up an animated conversation with Nato. However, for all the US talk of support for Pakistan’s shaky civilian government — and President Obama’s dismissal of the wayward Gen McChrystal — Gen Kayani was the dominant Pakistani participant at the US-Pakistan ‘strategic’ dialogue held in March this year.

That may have defused tensions with the general over the Kerry-Lugar Bill — the army, it seems, was furious that US aid was being channelled to the people through the civilian government, rather than used for buying arms — but it certainly did little to lift the morale of Pakistan’s civilian government. Revealingly, at a press conference in Brussels earlier this month, Prime Minister Yousuf Raza Gilani made a point of referring to the fact that the “Pakistani government and the army” saw eye to eye on fighting extremism in the country.

Perhaps Mr Gilani and Gen Kayani should take advice from Thailand’s Foreign Minister Kasit Piromya who, in talks in Brussels recently, warned the country’s generals that any military intervention would “close Thailand from the outside world”. “I am optimistic there will be no military takeover,” said Mr Piromya, adding: “the military works under civilian control.” He was clear, however, that the civilian government “had to get the respect of the army”.

Thailand has, of course, just gone through its worst violence and turmoil in history, marked by confrontations between pro- and anti-government protesters. Acting ahead of the demonstrations, the Thai government imposed the Internal Security Act, putting the military in charge with powers to impose curfews, restrict numbers at gatherings and set up check points. With 88 people dead during the rioting, Prime Minister Abhisit Vejjajiva recently set up a fact-finding mission to determine whether the army used undue force against the civilians.

Which brings us to Turkey — the country that Indonesia, Thailand and Pakistan look up to as having managed to find a formula for keeping the military in check. True, the government of Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan has returned the once all-powerful army — four coups in as many decades — to the barracks.

Unfortunately, however, Mr Erdogan’s religious-oriented political party is engaged in a permanent battle with the secular Turkish army to win the public’s hearts and minds. Many Turkish officers see the current government as trying to undo the country’s secular constitution. Rumours of planned coups and counter-coups abound in Istanbul and are the daily fodder of the country’s many newspapers.

In an ideal world, the civil-military relationship should be based on mutual respect, cooperation and a share-out of the burdens of governance. Armies are needed to protect nations from foreign enemies and, in some unfortunate cases, internal ones as well. Real life, however, is more complicated. As Gen McChrystal has shown, boys will be boys — especially when they have large guns in their hands.

The writer is Dawn’s correspondent in Brussels.

Editoral-Islands for sale

By Elena Moya
Saturday, 26 Jun, 2010
THERE’S little that shouts ‘seriously rich’ as much as a little island in the sun to call your own. For Sir Richard Branson it is Neckar in the Caribbean, the billionaire Barclay brothers prefer Brecqhou in the Channel Islands, while Aristotle Onassis married Jackie Kennedy on Skorpios, his Greek hideway.

Now Greece is making it easier for the rich and famous to fulfil their dreams by preparing to sell, or offering long-term leases on, some of its 6,000 sun-kissed islands in a desperate attempt to repay its mountainous debts.

The Guardian has learned that an area on Mykonos, one of Greece’s top tourist destinations, is one of the sites for sale. The area is one-third owned by the government, which is looking for a buyer willing to inject capital and develop a luxury tourism complex, according to a source close to the negotiations.

— The Guardian, London

Editoral-Anti-narcotics policy

On the International Day against Drug Abuse and Illicit Trafficking, there is no better way for the government to renew its commitment to a narcotics-free society than by having the cabinet approve the new national anti-narcotics policy. It was in 2000-01 that we eradicated poppy cultivation and achieved poppy-free status, thanks to the first anti-narcotics policy, 1993. However, with no new policy, success in reducing the production of narcotics in the 1990s was not matched by similar progress on the drug-trafficking and drug-addiction fronts. Thus trafficking in drugs increased and drug addiction rose from three million drug addicts in 1993 to, reportedly, at least six million today, with one in 10 college/university student said to be an addict.

How sincere the government is in its commitment to reducing drug abuse can be judged by the goals of the Anti-Narcotics Policy 2010. Any effective policy must go beyond maintaining a poppy-free status, and mop up what we failed to stem in the first decade of the 21st century. The new policy should address what the latest World Drug Report 2010 says is a growing new trend — the use of synthetic drugs or amphetamine-type stimulants.

New narcotics control measures in the 2010 policy, like the creation of an inter-agency task force, the setting up of parliamentary committees on narcotics control and the enhancement of treatment and rehabilitation facilities, are important. But to forestall a shift in the 2010s from the abuse of opium and heroin to the use of new addictive substances that can easily be manufactured in clandestine laboratories from legal and readily available chemical raw materials the government will need to act now. It must control the sale and purchase of such chemicals. It must also carry out a narcotics survey regularly to assess emerging trends and the extent of abuse.

Editoral-Rampant deforestation

A slaughter is in progress across the country. We are destroying the environment with little regard for the ecological and socio-economic consequences of this plunder that benefits an elect few and damages the health and livelihoods of the poor. Species are dying out and our rivers and harbours have been turned into toxic cesspools. Officialdom’s apathy in all this is appalling and yet understandable because in many cases it is a party to the devastation. Take deforestation, which is just one of many environmental issues of grave concern.

The latest findings of the World Wide Fund for Nature reveal that Pakistan’s already meagre forest cover is being depleted by 2.1 per cent, the highest annual deforestation rate in Asia. Much of this reduction can be attributed to the official policy of changing the status of forest lands and allowing their use for other purposes. According to the WWF, more than 150,000 acres of forest have been lost in this way since the country’s inception in 1947. Encroachers and commercial harvesters, often called the timber mafia, have also played havoc with their authorised as well as illegal felling.

Pakistan’s once lush mangrove stands, which serve as natural hatcheries and offer protection against tidal surges, have taken the biggest hit with an annual depletion rate of nearly 2.3 per cent. Estimates vary but it is believed that the mangrove cover along the coast has fallen from nearly 1.5 million acres in 1966 to just about 420,000 acres today, and even this shockingly low count is seen by some as generous. Deforestation, be it in the Indus delta or the mountains, carries severe socio-economic costs. The livelihoods and way of life of local communities that use forests in sustainable ways — collecting fallen branches for fuel, grazing livestock, etc — can be ruined beyond repair by rampant logging. Deforestation is also associated with climate change while Pakistan has already seen an increase in deadly landslides, flash floods and the silting of major dams. All this is preventable and reforestation is the need of the hour. But for that to happen we need rulers who actually care.

Editoral-Fake degrees

The ‘fake degrees’ issue continues to rumble on, injecting a fresh element of uncertainty in the assemblies. On Thursday, the Supreme Court ordered the Election Commission of Pakistan to initiate proceedings against the fake-degree holders which could lead to their eventual disqualification from the various assemblies. The matter is not so straightforward, however: a legal thicket means that it’s not clear if the ECP can proceed of its own accord — thus far it has maintained that it would require references from the speakers of the various assemblies and the chairman of the Senate. Before that can happen, though, the National Assembly may attempt some sort of legislation that could try and resolve the matter.

The background to all of this is of course Gen Musharraf’s tinkering with election-related laws in an attempt to keep political rivals out of the assemblies. When the time for nominations for the February 2008 elections rolled around, the degree requirement had been challenged in the Supreme Court and it was expected that it would be done away with. However, since it was still the law at the time nominations were to be made, the ECP requested all candidates to submit their higher educational degrees. Which is why, as estimated by the former secretary of the ECP, perhaps 140 members of the various assemblies filed fake degrees. Many, if not most, of those are believed to belong to the PML-N, which is acutely embarrassed that its era of ‘principled politics’ is being undermined so publicly.

At this point, a measure of pragmatism is required. If 140 members, and perhaps more, stand to be disqualified, an equivalent number of by-elections will have to be held. A mini mid-term election is not something the country needs presently. One way of looking at the fake degrees issue is that assembly members have lied in order to get elected and should be punished. But from the declaration of assets to campaign spending, candidates routinely lie and on a much bigger scale. In the case of fake degrees, however, it was a procedural hurdle deliberately put in place by Gen Musharraf to trip up candidates who the electorate might otherwise have genuinely elected. This of course does not justify the lie. And the Supreme Court was right to ignore the context and focus on what the law says. Given all of this perhaps a political-cum-legislative solution is the best away ahead. Legislation with retrospective effect is not something that should be encouraged, especially where it benefits assembly members themselves, but in the present instance it would be a small price to pay for righting a wrong of Gen Musharraf’s doing.

Editoral-The two Punjabs

By A.G. Noorani
Saturday, 26 Jun, 2010
A ‘WATER CRISIS’ has emerged of late from the shadows to claim the spotlight in relations between Pakistan and India. It has begun to jostle with other items on an already crowded agenda in their dialogue in an unseemly and desperate bid to elbow them down and lay a false claim to primacy for itself at the top of the agenda.

The so-called ‘water crisis’ does not deserve that place. The thoughtfully crafted Indus Waters Treaty of 1960 has stood the test of time and provides for a precise and effective mechanism for conflict-resolution. Not all the problems, however, arise from a conflict of interests, rights or perceptions. Some have been created by climate change; some by increase of population; not a few are due to sheer mismanagement and waste. Disagreements on the Kishanganga project on the Indian side of the LoC in Kashmir and the Neelam-Jhelum project on the Pakistan side in Kashmir and the Nimoo Bazgo project in Leh will follow the procedures set by the precedent of Baglihar.

It is the larger problems that both countries must jointly face — climate change and consequential depletion of river flows, pressures of growing population and waste — in a non-partisan way; for, they affect both. It was in this spirit that the Indus Waters Treaty was concluded. The idea was mooted in a seminal article in the now defunct Collier’s in the United States in the issue of Aug 4, 1951. It was written by David E. Lilienthal who had won fame as the chairman of the Tennessee Valley Authority. He suggested “a joint use of this truly international river basin on an engineering basis”. Ideas can shape policies and policies can change the political climate from an adversarial one to a cooperative enterprise.

A recent article by Dr Manohar Singh Gill in The Hindu of May 29 is refreshingly free from polemics and makes a powerful plea for cooperation between the two countries. Entitled ‘Water crisis of east and west Punjab’ it argues that both sides will have to rise above politics and focus on the water crisis which requires difficult solutions.

Dr Gill, now minister of youth affairs and sports at the centre, was a civil servant and served as development commissioner, Punjab from 1985 to 1988 and rose to be chief election commissioner. He recalls the warning given by Calvert, ICS, in 1928 in his classic book The Wealth and Welfare of the Punjab, of the dangers of undue dependence on rivers, dams, rainfall and tube-wells. In a convocation address at the Punjab Agricultural University in Ludhiana on Nov 5, 1998 he had predicted a water crisis and tension “within and without” Punjab on the question of water. What will be the state of things a decade from now?

He now writes: “Sixty years have drastically reduced the comfort of 1950 on both sides. In Pakistan, the population growth from 50 million to 175 million has put an unacceptable burden. This has reduced the water availability per capita, per year, from 5,000 cubic feet in 1960 to 1,500 today. In our Punjab too, the population has increased over 60 years but at a lesser rate. In 1947, in east Punjab, 6,000 cubic metres of potable water was available per person, per year. Now it is only 1,600 cubic metres. It is estimated to fall further to 1,147 cubic metres in 2050.

“However, the nine lakh shallow tube-wells now dangle dry. The rich have started digging deep to 300 feet or more with submersible pumps to grab water. Small farmers who predominate cannot afford the cost and their wells are drying up. One deep tube-well will dry up 100 (tube-wells) around it. The water table has gone far down, and this situation will lead to social tension. …West Punjab too faces these grave questions.”

Dr Gill offers concrete suggestions to be followed within Indian Punjab and in cooperation with the Punjab in Pakistan. “What should the two Punjabs do?” One proposal is to license and regulate tube-well sinking, including the permissible depth. “All must share fairly, and not take the maximum by means of wealth and power.” Monitoring is easy in this computer age. A high commissioner for groundwater management for the Punjab, with a competent scientific staff, would report directly to the chief minister and present an annual report to the state assembly. “Our British canals are in a state of collapse and flood irrigation will not do.”

He has a word of advice “for my friends in West Punjab”. Only recently the foreign minister of Pakistan, Mr Shah Mehmood Qureshi, said in a TV interview that the total average canal supplies of Pakistan are 104 million acre feet while the water available at the four gates is about 70 million acre feet. “Where does the 34 million acre feet go? It is not being stolen by India. It has been wasted in Pakistan.”

Therein lies the wisdom of Dr Gill’s advice. “Both Punjabs should face up to the water crisis, with courage and steady application of science. Else, they will be in trouble which won’t go away” — a dire prediction, indeed. The solution lies in a joint harnessing of scientific knowledge. The Punjab Agricultural University in Ludhiana can invite an academic from Pakistan to serve on its faculty for a year or so and the Punjab University in Lahore can reciprocate. India-Pakistan seminars on the subject can help. So can joint studies by independent experts. The chief ministers of the two Punjabs have met before. They should do so again before long to set afoot a dialogue at various levels, academic and otherwise, which will help their respective national governments the better to understand the ‘water crisis’ and drive the demagogues to find other topics to keep their business going.

As for Pakistan and India, they would render high service to the people of Kashmir if, without prejudice to their rights under the Indus Waters Treaty, they set up a single joint project on the Kishanganga-Jhelum-Neelam sharing electricity for both sides of the LoC rather than two rival hydroelectric projects in the same area. The power-starved people of Kashmir will thank them for it.

The writer is a writer and a lawyer.

Editoral-A culture of mistrust

By Aslam Pervaiz Abro
Saturday, 26 Jun, 2010
A RECENT survey conducted by Transparency International Pakistan (TIP) is a grim reminder of the fact that corruption continues to be viewed as one the gravest problems facing the country.

The report, the National Corruption Perception Survey 2010 (NCPS), was comprised of a 24-page questionnaire filled out by 5,200 respondents from all four provinces.

It states that corruption has escalated to the extent that the amount involved in overall misappropriation has reached Rs223bn in 2010 as compared to Rs195bn in 2009. It ranks police and power as the two sectors perceived as the most corrupt and pins land administration and the education department at number three and four respectively.

TIP’s findings are not unfounded and appear to reflect the realities that keep the country mired in backwardness. Syed Adil Gilani, the chairman of TIP, correctly indicated that corruption “is the root cause of poverty, illiteracy, terrorism, shortage of electricity, food etc and lack of governance in Pakistan”.

The survey highlights that 70 per cent of the respondents think that the current government is more corrupt than the previous one. It is axiomatic that people have become disillusioned and frustrated, believing that their expectations have been left unfulfilled by the government they elected to end a long period of dictatorship. Going by the respondents’ views, then, the citizens seem to have lost trust in the current set-up and appear confused when it comes to drawing a distinction between dictatorship and democracy.

The four sectors that the NCPS 2010 ranked as being perceived as the most corrupt are public service departments where any kind of malpractice has a direct bearing on the life of ordinary citizens. Amongst the major reasons that government departments, including the four seen as the worst affected, are riddled with corruption are excessive political influence and the government’s cavalier attitude towards corrective action.

In the police department, political meddling remains the order of the day. Money comes easily to the policeman who abuses his power for the purpose of extortion. With political backing, the corrupt policeman gets away with malpractice even if a departmental inquiry is instituted. While there is talk about reforms in several sectors, the legislators remain silent on the need to reform the police.

The Police Order 2002, which provides for checks and balances on police power, is being done away with by the present government which considers it non-workable. Yet no substitute legislation laying emphasis on accountability is in evidence.

The report indicts the power sector perceived as being callously corrupt. This is hardly surprising since blackouts have added immensely to people’s miseries. The stealing of electricity through kundas or illegal hook-ups is a common practice that can be seen in the streets of almost every town in the country. Yet Wapda employees look the other way or even collude in the malpractice: the limitless consumption of ‘free’ electricity is just a matter of paying a few hundred rupees to the lineman.

Thus, electricity shortage was bound to happen. The short-term measures adopted by the government, including the reduction in the number of working days, the closure of businesses at 8pm and the stress on independent power producers — whose process of tender is questionable in terms of transparency — cannot bear fruit until corruption is eradicated.

According to the NCPS 2010, land administration is the third most corrupt sector in Pakistan. The land mafia, in palpable connivance with government officials and politicians, can in many areas be found to be illegally occupying government land and public areas designated for parks, playgrounds, etc.

Take the example of Sindh Goth Abad (Housing Scheme) Act 1987 which provides for the allocation of land, free of charge, to poor people. Under this scheme, the land mafia has grabbed thousands of acres in Karachi and has been selling it to people against the payment of hundreds of thousand rupees. Some observers believe that the current spate of targeted killing in Karachi is related to land grabbing.

Land records, which are currently manually maintained, must be computerised to insulate them from patwaris’ and tehsildars’ manipulations: in many cases, such officials favour those who offer bribes.

Such widespread corruption is a result of the absence of a viable accountability system that enforces anti-corruption laws. The general public cannot help but lose trust in state institutions whose organisational heads, even at the town and district level, acquire postings through bribes.

This is a situation that leads to a culture of mistrust and dashes the citizenry’s hope for justice. This was recently seen when the Supreme Court ordered the set-up of a National Accountability Bureau investigation team headed by Tariq Khosa, ex-director general of the Federal Investigation Agency, to investigate the Bank of Punjab scam.

Invoking Section 27 of the National Accountability Ordinance, 1999, the chairman NAB wrote to the Establishment Division to requisition the services of Mr Khosa. The government turned down the request and appointed Aftab Sultan, additional inspector general of police in Punjab, as head of the NAB investigation team.

Whether it is Mr Sultan or Mr Khosa, the Supreme Court’s directive that a third person from a different department be appointed to head the NAB investigation team constitutes a question mark regarding the bureau’s efficiency and credibility in investigating a high-profile corruption case.

The Supreme Court seems to have given this order in view of the NAB officials’ inability to grill many big guns involved in the scam. The matter has to be viewed in context of the fact that NAB has so far shied away from examining the federal law minister — the bureau’s boss: the accused in the case, Sheikh Muhammad Afzal, has alleged that the minister received Rs35m for getting a court verdict in favour of the accused.

Editoral-Russia’s slow modernisation

By Simon Tisdall
Saturday, 26 Jun, 2010
PRESIDENT Dmitry Medvedev this week stepped up his campaign to convince the West that Russia can be counted on as a reliable political and business partner. But even as he toured California and talked of creating a Russian equivalent of Silicon Valley, Prime Minister Vladimir Putin was up to his old tricks.

While continuing to deny Russia uses its energy exports as a geopolitical weapon, Putin, the former president, warned neighbouring Belarus it could face a total shutdown in gas supplies unless it knuckled under. On Thursday Russian gas producer Gazprom said it was resuming supplies to Belarus after it paid £133m for previous shipments.

The row was ostensibly about the debt. But the context is Kremlin displeasure at Minsk’s decision to take in the deposed president of Kyrgyzstan, Kurmanbek Bakiyev, ousted in a Moscow-backed coup this year. The dispute recalled rows with Ukraine that caused energy shortages across Europe. Ukraine elected a more amenable government, which agreed to extend the Russian Black Sea fleet’s lease on port facilities in Sevastopol. As if by magic, Gazprom lowered gas prices for Kiev.

Against this backdrop, Medvedev took his message of a modernising Russia to the White House, where he and Barack Obama were expected to discuss economic cooperation. He is due to meet the British premier David Cameron at the G8 summit in Canada. But Obama and Cameron face a similar dilemma.

The US has tried to ‘reset’ relations with Moscow since George Bush left office, brokering deals on nuclear weapons reductions and Iran sanctions. Yet it is concerned about authoritarian trends within Russia and strategic issues such as the government’s uncompromising stance towards former Soviet republics within its ‘sphere of influence’.

Recent moves to enhance the surveillance powers of the FSB (the successor to Putin’s KGB), attempts to block a book about Putin by opposition politician Boris Nemtsov, the politicised trial of former tycoon Mikhail Khodorkovsky and the failure to solve more than a dozen murders involving human rights advocates and investigative journalists appear at odds with Medvedev’s vision of a transformed Russia.

Last week Mikhail Gorbachev, the reformist former Soviet leader, said Russia was halfway through the transition from communist monolith to modern state. “Modernisation can be carried out but only if the people are included ... We need democracy, we need improvement of the electoral system. Without that, it will not succeed,” he said.

British officials say Cameron is hoping for a “substantive” meeting with Medvedev; the Russian ambassador to London has suggested a fresh page could be turned in bilateral relations. But Britain shares Washington’s concerns and has some of its own, notably Russia’s refusal to extradite Andrei Lugovoy, a former KGB officer sought in connection with the 2006 murder of Alexander Litvinenko in London.

Still, Obama and Cameron are likely to encourage Medvedev’s modernisation campaign, hoping perhaps to strengthen his hand in what may become a power struggle with Putin ahead of the 2012 presidential election. Putin has refused to say whether he will stand.

Working in Medvedev’s favour is the growing realisation that a more diversified economy, less state control and more private sector businesses are essential for the country’s long-term health. Russia’s economy contracted last year by 7.9 per cent, following worldwide falls in commodity prices, boosting Medvedev’s argument that it is too reliant on energy exports.

Medvedev’s ability to influence the way Putin runs the country is limited. But he may be gaining in confidence.

— The Guardian, London

US for stable govt in Pakistan

June 25: President Barack Obama has said that the United States wants stable and strong governments in Pakistan and Afghanistan that could defeat terrorists.

In a joint news conference with Russian President Dmitry Medvedev, President Obama said his decision to send a new commander to Afghanistan was “a change in personnel but not a change in policy”.

The US mission in the Pak-Afghan region was, first and foremost, to dismantle and destroy Al Qaeda and its affiliates so that they could not attack the United States again, he said.

“In order to achieve that, we have to make sure that we have a stable Afghan government, and we also have to make sure that we’ve got a Pakistani government that is working effectively with us to dismantle these networks,” he said.

Petraeus to change rules of engagement

June 25: US Defence Secretary Robert Gates has said that the new US commander in Afghanistan Gen David Petraeus will have more ‘flexibility’ than his predecessor in drawing up his strategy for defeating the militants.

Gen Petraeus will “have the flexibility to look at the campaign plan and the approach and all manner of things when he gets to Afghanistan”, Mr Gates told a Pentagon briefing on Thursday.

Chairman of the US Joint Chiefs of Staff Admiral Mike Mullen told the same briefing that Gen Petraeus would be able to make tactical changes.

And the US media reported on Friday that one of the first things the general would do was to modify the controversial rules of engagement to make it easier for US troops to engage in combat with the enemy. US military officers in Afghanistan often complain that strict rules – aimed at preventing civilian casualties – have effectively forced the troops to fight with one hand tied behind their backs.

Secretary Gates also indicated that President Obama’s decision to send a senior and experienced general like Mr Petraeus to Afghanistan showed that the administration too was keen on ending this conflict as quickly as possible but without causing further chaos in the region.

Mr Gates said that Gen Petraeus’s close relationship with the Pakistani military and his familiarity with the present set-up in Afghanistan were the key reasons for his appointment.

Govt nets Rs315 billion from oil taxes

The government is estimated to have earned about Rs315 billion in taxes on oil business during the current fiscal year, making it the single largest revenue-contributing sector. But this contributed to the overall inflationary trends.

Sources in the petroleum ministry told Dawn on Friday the government earned about Rs115 billion as general sales tax on domestic sale of petroleum products during 2009-10 and Rs90 billion was recovered on POL imports.

The total sales collection on petroleum products stood at Rs205 billion.

Likewise, the government netted about Rs108 billion during the current fiscal year on account of petroleum levy on oil products.

Besides, a 16 per cent variable general sales tax on all petroleum products being charged to consumers, the government collected a fixed petroleum levy at the rate of Rs10 per litre on petrol, Rs14 on high octane blending component, Rs6 on kerosene, Rs3 on LDO and Rs8 on high speed diesel.

The government earns on an average about Rs10 billion per month as petroleum levy on five petroleum products, namely high speed diesel, light diesel oil, kerosene, HOBC and petrol.

The government had set a budgetary target to collect about Rs122 billion during the current fiscal year on account of petroleum levy that was originally introduced as carbon tax, but later renamed as petroleum levy when the Supreme Court raised questions about the utilisation of carbon tax.

The petroleum levy target was later revised to Rs110 billion, said the source, adding the actual collection under this head had now been estimated at about Rs108 billion.

The government currently collects about Rs20 per litre on petrol, Rs26 on high octane blending component, Rs15 per litre on kerosene and Rs12 on light diesel oil from consumers.

In addition, about Rs8.91 is paid to the oil companies and dealers on petrol, Rs11.93 per litre on high octane, Rs3.23 per litre on kerosene and Rs4.27 on light diesel oil.

Pakistan’s total sales tax collection during the current fiscal year has amounted to about Rs500 billion, against Rs430 billion in the previous year—an increase of about 16pc.

A senior government official said that higher electricity tariffs and petroleum prices during the outgoing fiscal year had resulted in substantial windfall revenues to the government, although these revenues had a negative impact on the purchasing power of the common people.

He said a robust growth in sales tax collection on POL product imports had been mainly because of massive growth in imports of motor spirit, furnace oil and JP-1 that was higher than the last year’s collection on these products to the extent of 560pc, 45pc and 150pc, respectively.

The sales tax collection from electricity went up by an unusual 40pc during the current fiscal year over last year.

Power tariffs have increased by more than 60pc in 15 months up to April.

This was despite the fact that the nation suffered long hours of loadshedding both in winter and summer.

Companies seek huge increases in gas tariff

Two gas utilities have sought Rs20.36 and Rs63.10 per unit increase in their prescribed prices with effect from July 1, to meet their revenue loss arising out of the government’s decision to increase excise duty on gas production by Rs5 per unit.

Informed sources told Dawn that the Sui Southern Gas Company Limited (SSGCL) and Sui Northern Gas Pipelines Limited (SNGPL) had submitted their review petitions before the Oil and Gas Regulatory Authority. The ogra had not only rejected their petitions for tariff increase, but also reduced their prescribed prices by Rs4.53 per unit.

Ogra sources said that the regulator had received the two review petitions.

A petroleum ministry official said that Ogra was unlikely to accept the two review petitions, although it would be obligated to allow about Rs4.90 per unit increase on account of the rise in excise duty. The gas companies will probably be allowed to raise prices proportionate to the rise in excise duty, the official added.

The two companies have pleaded that because of the government’s decision to increase excise duty on wellhead prices, it would not be possible for them to pay for gas purchases from producers.

In the federal budget 2010-11, the government has raised the excise duty on natural gas from Rs5.09 at present to Rs10 per MMBTU. The decision will bring in an additional revenue of Rs7 billion. The money will go to Sindh in keeping with an understanding reached during negotiations for NFC award.

The government has already decided not to pass on an average Rs4.53 per unit reduction in natural gas tariff approved by Ogra to mop up Sindh government’s gas-related revenue loss under the National Finance Commission Award.

Ogra had decided on May 18 to reduce prices of natural gas by an average of 2.55 per cent, or Rs4.55 per unit, for all categories of consumers from July 1. A notification for maintaining gas rates is likely to be issued by next week.

Sindh had agreed during the NFC talks to allow Balochistan to have higher returns on gas produced from that province for the last few decades to address longstanding grievances of the people of Balochistan.

The Ogra’s May 18 determination said the prices of gas for domestic, commercial, industrial, CNG stations, fertiliser, cement and power generation would come down both for SNGPL and SSGCL.

The two gas utilities had sought an increase in tariff at the rate of Rs20.36 and Rs63.10 per million British thermal unit (MMBTU), respectively, but Ogra held that average tariff for both companies should be reduced by Rs4.53 per cent.

Pakistan-India talks make wary start

Quite in contrast to the cordiality that marked the Pakistan-India foreign secretaries’ talks one day ago, the interior ministers of the two countries found it difficult to move towards a breakthrough on counter-terrorism cooperation as they opened their talks on Friday.

The two ministers are likely to meet again on Saturday.

Indian Home Minister Palaniappan Chidambaram, who is the first minister from Delhi to visit Pakistan since the 2008 Mumbai attacks, met his Pakistani counterpart, Rehman Malik, for talks on terrorism, a subject which stopped the normalisation of relations after the terror strikes.

Their meeting was preceded by the interior secretaries’ meeting earlier in the day for setting an agenda of the talks.

The outcome of the foreign secretaries’ and the interior ministers’ parleys is certain to set the tone for a meeting between the two foreign ministers next month. That dialogue is likely to lay out a strategy for overcoming the trust deficit between Islamabad and New Delhi.

The foreign secretaries had agreed on Thursday on the need for jointly dealing with terrorism, but had left it to the interior ministers to work out the nitty gritty.

There was no official word from either side after the meeting, but sources privy to the discussions warned against expecting any ‘dramatic development or grand gestures’.

Indications were that the two leaders might settle for an incremental progress beginning with small-scale confidence-building measures like release of detained fishermen, reactivation of the judicial commission on prisoners, return of confiscated boats and simplifying procedures for dealing with inadvertent border crossings and violations of maritime boundaries by fishermen. During his talks with the interior minister, Mr Chidambaram expressed dissatisfaction over the trial of the alleged perpetrators of the Mumbai attacks and said his government felt that Pakistan was not pursuing the prosecution wholeheartedly.

Mr Malik asked India to respect Pakistani courts’ decisions in the Mumbai attacks case just as it honoured an Indian court’s verdict in the trial of Ajmal Kasab, a source said.

Mr Chidambaram shared the findings of interrogation of Lashkar-i-Taiba operative David Headley by an Indian team in the US. Some of the findings were earlier shared in the latest dossier given by India to Pakistan a few days back.

He also took up accusations of an increase in infiltration into held Kashmir from the Pakistani side. The Indian side was of the view that Pakistan had not taken the action required against Jamaatud Dawa (JuD) chief Hafiz Saeed, the alleged mastermind of the Nov 26, 2008, attacks.

Mr Malik said as no credible evidence had been found to substantiate the allegations, the court could not take any action against him.

He said Pakistan had asked the Indian government to hand over the principal accused, but the plea was turned down in the light of a court decision. “We honoured the Indian court’s decision in that case.”

Mr Chidambaram asked Pakistani authorities to hold a speedy trial of those accused of planning the attacks.

Mr Malik reiterated allegations of Indian sponsorship of sabotage activities in Pakistan, particularly in Balochistan and the tribal areas.

Mr Chidambaram later called on Foreign Minister Shah Mehmood Qureshi.

“The two ministers expressed the desire for developing friendly, cooperative and good-neighbourly relations between the two countries. The need for a sustained and comprehensive dialogue to build trust and confidence was emphasised,” the Foreign Office spokesman said after the meeting.

The Indian minister is also likely to meet President Asif Ali Zardari and Prime Minister Yousuf Raza Gilani.

SAARC CONFERENCE: Mr Chidambaram will represent India at a meeting of the home ministers of the South Asian Association for Regional Cooperation (Saarc) on Saturday.

On the third day of the regional conference, member countries expressed their resolve to formulate a joint strategy to fight terrorism, drug smuggling, human trafficking and other cross-border crimes.

Friday, June 25, 2010

Editoral-OHER VOICES - Pushto Press Peace in Balochistan

BALOCHISTAN Chief Minister Nawab Aslam Raisani has reiterated that no military operation was under way in the province and that the law and order situation was better as compared to other places. Talking to media personnel, he said the Balochistan package had created employment opportunities … and the provincial budget was people-friendly. The chief minister said the government was planning to develop new roads and hospitals … [and] advised youngsters to avail job opportunities in the Frontier Constabulary and Pakistan Army. He advised youngsters to throw away weapons and try solving their problems with the power of democracy.

…[In fact] the law and order situation has deteriorated…. Thousands of Baloch are missing. …The government should hold talks with Baloch nationalists and try to resolve issues with them. …The maintenance of peace should be the ultimate goal of the present government…. — (June 21)

Illegitimate interference

…THE future of the US mission in war-torn Afghanistan is in a shambles and … countries are refusing to end their proxy wars on Afghan soil. The Afghan foreign affairs ministry has now accused the Iranian government of interfering in Afghanistan’s internal affairs. The International Security Assistance Force spokesman in Afghanistan … also said the same. According to the ISAF spokesman there is evidence that Iran is supplying money and ammunition to government opposition forces inside Afghanistan.

…[S]ome Afghan parliamentarians also claim to have evidence that Iran supplies arms to Afghan insurgents in coordination with its intelligence agency. Ahmed Waheed Tahiri, an Afghan MP, claimed … that Iran has transported 800 kg of explosives, 1,000 heavy weapons and some other light weapons to Afghanistan in the last two weeks. …All regional countries should help the Afghan government restore peace … — (June 23)

Editoral-Whaling talks collapse

THOUSANDS of whales will continue to be killed each year following the collapse on Wednesday of international negotiations to redraw whaling rules after two intense days of secret talks.

Nonetheless, anti-whaling groups hailed the collapse as a success, as it means the ban on whaling — introduced 24 years ago but ignored by some nations — remains in place.

Pro and anti-whaling countries failed to reach a compromise agreement at the meeting of the 88 member countries of the International Whaling Commission (IWC) in Agadir, Morocco.

Acting IWC chairman Anthony Liverpool said “fundamental positions remained very much apart” while chief US delegate Monica Medina said: “After nearly three years of discussions, it appears we are at an impasse.”

Pro-whaling countries Japan, Norway and Iceland — with backing from the US, New Zealand and some green groups — had proposed lifting a ban on commercial whaling in return for cutting the number of whales killed under quotas that would reduce over a 10-year period.

But Britain, Australia and Latin American countries opposed ending the moratorium.

The failure to reach a consensus means the issue has been put to one side for at least a year. The result also calls into question the future of the IWC, with documents (PDF) published at the meeting saying “the status quo is not an option for an effective multilateral organisation”.

But the current situation, in which Norway and Iceland hunt whales despite the IWC ban and Japan uses a “scientific whaling” loophole to hunt 1,000 mostly minke whales, will now continue.

Wendy Elliott at WWF, which along with Greenpeace and the Pew Environment Group issued a statement on Monday backing a lifting of the ban under certain conditions, was disappointed at the outcome.

“Governments failed to find a way forward,” she said. “Once again, they have put politics before science.

“This brings into question the integrity of the commission and its ability to make meaningful decisions that benefit whale conservation.”

Japanese whaling commissioner Yasue Funayama said her country had offered major concessions to reach a compromise and blamed anti-whaling nations which refused to accept the killing of a single animal.

“We must rise above politics and engage in a broader perspective,” she said. The head of the New Zealand delegation, Geoffrey Palmer, blamed an “absence of political will”.

Richard Benyon, Britain’s minister for the marine environment, said: “It is hugely disappointing that the world could not come together to give greater protection to these magnificent creatures.

“We in the UK have been consistently clear that any new agreement must reduce the numbers of whales that are killed each year with the aim of a complete phase-out of all commercial whaling.

But anti-whaling campaigners hailed the breakdown as a victory. “We have won the battle to keep the ban in place but must continue to fight to win the war on all whaling,” said Whale and Dolphin Conservation Society CEO Chris Butler-Stroud.

“We must not forget that Japan, Iceland and Norway continue to whale outside of the sanction of the IWC, and that is a situation that has to change. Their whaling activities must come to an end once and for all.”

The negotiations also took place in the shadow of corruption claims, with newspaper allegations suggesting Japan had bought countries’ pro-whaling votes by paying for flights and IWC membership fees, a charge that was denied.

— The Guardian, London

Editoral-Islam’s stress on environment

THE verse, “Corruption has spread in the land and the sea because of what they had committed” (30:41), seems to refer to the trespasses that human beings have committed against nature, leading the earth at a dizzying speed to an impending ecological disaster.

Muslims need to look at the Islamic scriptures to determine their spiritual and ethical framework regarding responsibility towards preserving the environment. In Surah Ibrahim it is said: “God is He who created the heavens and the earth, and sent down water from the sky, then brought forth fruits with it for you to eat. He gave the ship under your control, so that it may sail on the waters by His command, as well as gave the rivers in your power.

“He made the sun and the moon to serve you, both obeying the same law, and made the night and the day useful to you. And (besides) gave you everything that you asked for. If you try to count the favours of God, you will not be able to. Indeed, human beings are unjust and ungrateful.” (14:32-34).

Being ungrateful also means not using a gift in the manner, and for the purpose, intended by the Giver. In Surah Al-Baqarah it is also said that everything on the earth has been created for ‘you’ (2:29). The ‘you’ here refers to all human beings including all future generations. We should take care of these blessings, and should realise our moral accountability to God as well as to the future generations, in order to fulfil the rights of Allah and the fellow human beings on us.

The Quran states that life was created from water (11:7; 21:30). The importance of water and its equitable distribution among the people and animals is stressed: “…We send down water from the sky, pure water, so as to bring to life with it a dead land and to quench the thirst of Our creatures, both animals and humans, in large numbers. We keep distributing it among them, so that they would reflect.” (25:48-50). According to the Quran, Prophet Saleh’s nation, the Thamud, was destroyed because they refused to share the food and water with the she-camel (11:64). Prophet Noah was warned of the imminent flood. He was taught, through revelation, to build a huge boat and to put on it a pair of every species of animals as well as his followers. This is a lesson in preserving the species, which had turned into endangered species and would have otherwise been wiped out by the flood. The command to save the animals came before the command to save the Believers (11:40).

That life is sacred is borne out by the fact that the Kaaba and its precincts, covering about 50,000 sq km, are a sanctuary (7:96; 28:57; 95:3), where the killing of the smallest of creatures and damaging the smallest of plants is strictly forbidden, when in a state of ihram (5:96). The meat of an animal becomes lawful only after asking for permission by pronouncing God’s name over it, at the time of slaughter. Indiscriminate killing of animals is a grave sin and disturbs the balance of nature resulting in disorder.

We are told, “God does not like disorder” (2: 205). Even hunting is permitted only in order to consume the meat and not for the pleasure of enjoying a sharp-shooting spree. The Prophet (PBUH) exhorted his followers to be kind to animals. He forbade giving them pain or killing them unnecessarily.

The Prophet taught: “God does not like those who waste” (7:31). Even as the head of his people he led a simple life, in which the resources of the earth were not wasted, requiring their just distribution. He taught people not to waste food; he wore simple clothes and slept and ate on the floor. He is reported to have emphasised the importance of planting trees, especially from which human beings and animals could eat, as a way of protecting the environment. He said that one should complete the process of planting a tree and not run away, even if the Day of Judgment suddenly approached.

Islam as a code of life assigns duties as well as responsibilities. In the light of the Quran and the Sunnah, we must realise that we are accountable and, therefore, strive to change and adapt our lifestyle and social structures in order to leave the world in a habitable state for future generations.

nilofar.ahmed58@gmail.com

Editoral-UK budget to ‘hit the poor harder’

BRITAIN’S leading experts on tax and spending on Wedneday strongly challenged UK chancellor (finance minister) George Osborne’s claims to have delivered a “tough but fair” budget, concluding that the measures in the emergency package would hit the poor harder than the rich.

The Institute for Fiscal Studies said the chancellor and the deputy prime minister and leader of the UK coalition’s junior partner Nick Clegg could only assert that the better off were the big losers from the austerity move by including reforms announced by Labour, such as the changes to pension contributions.

The think tank gave its view as the prime minister David Cameron came under House of Commons pressure to justify the insistence that the budget was fair, and as Osborne admitted he was looking for extra welfare savings to spare government departments, other than health and international development, from cuts averaging 25 per cent during this parliament.

Noting that Britain was facing the “longest, deepest, sustained cuts in public spending since the Second World War, Robert Chote, the IFS director, said: “Osborne and Clegg have been keen to describe the measures as progressive in the sense that the rich will feel more pain than the poor. That is a debatable claim. The budget looks less progressive — indeed somewhat regressive — when you take out the effect of measures that were inherited from the previous government, when you look further into the future than 2012-13, and when you include some other measures that the treasury has chosen not to model.”

The IFS estimates that the squeeze on poorer families would increase in the second half of the parliament as welfare cuts kicked in and the two-year increase in child tax credit ended.

Yvette Cooper, the Labour opposition work and pensions spokeswoman, said: “The IFS has confirmed today exactly what we thought yesterday: that George Osborne’s budget was a typical Tory budget — unfair and hitting those on lower incomes hardest. So much for ‘we’re all in this together’.”

Osborne’s aides said that it was legitimate for the government to include pre-announced measures in its analysis of fairness. It was arbitrary to look at Wednesday’s measures in isolation. “What matters is what happens over the course of this parliament,” one said, adding that the richest 10 per cent of the population suffered most from the budget once both (previous chancellor) Alistair Darling’s and Osborne’s measures were taken into account.

The IFS found that the richest 10 per cent would be 7.5 per cent worse off by 2014-15 because of measures coming into force during the current parliament but that almost seven percentage points of that was due to Labour changes.

— The Guardian, London

Editoral-A progressive budget

There are a number of pleasant surprises in Gilgit-Baltistan’s first budget. Firstly, the territory has divided the Rs12.98bn budget almost down the line, with Rs6.4bn earmarked for non-development expenditure and the rest going towards development spending. The creation of 1,500 new jobs has been announced. But perhaps the most welcome aspect is that a quarter of the budget for FY2010-2011 has been set aside for education. The number of scholarships for students from Gilgit-Baltistan studying in other parts of Pakistan has also been doubled. This indicates that the Gilgit-Baltistan government has its priorities right. Its finance minister has also announced austerity measures, saying that the government’s operating expenses had been reduced by 26.5 per cent while expenses on entertainment, gifts and purchase of physical assets had been frozen.

However, there is room for improvement. The revenue target is a little over Rs355m and the vast chunk of the budget consists of federal money. But considering the fact that the territory was granted greater autonomy only in August last year, it will take time before it can develop a proper economic infrastructure. The elected representatives along with the federal authorities must chalk out a strategy that will help Gilgit-Baltistan generate more income and reduce dependence on Islamabad.

Observers say that if Gilgit-Baltistan is given a greater share of the revenue generated by the Sost dry port — a gateway to trade with China — it will go a long way towards improving financial autonomy. Also, Gilgit-Baltistan’s tourism potential must be tapped. With its natural beauty the region can be a magnet for tourists if the proper infrastructure is in place. If the Gilgit-Baltistan government follows up on the promises made in the budget and gradually improves revenue generation, it may prove to be an example worth emulating for progressive fiscal management.

Editoral-Websites’ blockade order

It is hard to grasp the logic behind the Lahore High Court’s decision to block search engines that allegedly carry blasphemous material. Anyone familiar with the Internet knows that search engines are essentially devoid of content: they merely throw up thousands of related web links in response to a user’s specific query. This means that a person affronted by ‘blasphemous’ material unearthed by, say, Google deliberately looked for it in the first place. No one forced him or her to visit an ‘offensive’ site and it seems implausible to argue that a search engine can be held responsible for every bit of information available on the web.

Yet, on Tuesday the LHC’s Bahawalpur bench ordered the Pakistan Telecommunication Authority to block nine websites including Google, Yahoo, MSN and Hotmail. An individual filed a petition and a judge ordered an interim ban without, apparently, consulting experts in the field of information technology. It can be asked here whether the order could have been reserved until June 28 when PTA officials are due to respond to the court’s queries. At the same time the public would not be amiss in questioning the role of the deputy attorney general, who supported the petition. To what extent did he brief the court on the technical aspects of the issue at hand?

Let’s pause here and take a look at the Internet as a whole. The information superhighway is, in short, full of information that we may or may not choose to access. It is possible to look up the lyrics of a song from one’s childhood or the views voiced on Aryan nation sites and those that support Al Qaeda and the Taliban. Blogs that are entertaining or boring can be read at the click of a mouse. There is sports news out there, as there are reports on meetings between world leaders. The point here is simple: everyone has a right to the information he or she seeks. Also let’s not forget that there is no compulsion involved, nor is it possible to police the Internet to the extent that some desire. Whatever happened to turning the other cheek? It’s simpler.

Editoral-Pakistan-India ties

Not much was expected in terms of public announcements from the meeting of the foreign secretaries of Pakistan and India yesterday in Islamabad and not much was offered afterwards for public consumption other than blandishments. With their bosses, the foreign ministers, set to meet on July 15, such meetings are invariably about setting the stage for higher-level interactions. From the perspective of nudging forward Pakistan-India relations, the meeting to be held between Interior Minister Rehman Malik and Home Minister P. Chidambaram may hold greater promise. Undeniably, terrorism is a key issue between the two countries at present. Yet, bizarrely, there is no effective mechanism for sharing intelligence on potential terrorist activities between the two countries.

The Joint Anti-Terrorism Mechanism set up in 2006 had become a posturing club, involving members of the bureaucracy who were content to exchange ‘wanted lists’ periodically. A more meaningful mechanism would involve the exchange of real-time intelligence between the two countries, and would almost surely require the active participation of the intelligence agencies on both sides. Messrs Malik and Chidambaram could use their meeting towards at least initiating such a process, one that would in concrete ways address some of India’s concerns on the terrorism front.

The fact of the matter is that big breakthroughs are not likely any time soon. Perhaps because of external, read US, pressure or perhaps because India is afraid the shifting tide in Afghanistan may jeopardise its investments there, India agreed to talk to Pakistan. But it’s striking that even now, some months after Indian Prime Minister Manmohan Singh made his surprise announcement, there is no decisive shift away from the Indian position post-Mumbai. What seems to have changed is more the tone and tenor rather than the substance of the conversations. Also not very encouraging is the lack of creative thinking on the Pakistani side.

As long as India clung to its ‘no composite dialogue’ line, Pakistan seemed to know what to say: restart the composite dialogue. But given some kind of ambiguity in the Indian position, Pakistan has not been able to put any new ideas on the table. To be sure, it’s in Pakistan’s interests to talk, and talk soon, about the ‘core’ issues, Kashmir, water, etc. Yet, diplomatic breakthroughs are not had by sitting back and sticking to traditional demands. In Prime Minister Singh, Pakistan has a potential peace partner who appears willing to at least go beyond the bare minimum in the quest for peace. Creative thinking here could give the latest ‘process’ the necessary impetus.

Share

Twitter Delicious Facebook Digg Stumbleupon Favorites More